AGORA

Agora issue guide

ICE explained: what it does, and what abolishing it would mean

By the Agora desk · Published · How we count player splits

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is the federal agency that arrests, detains and deports people inside the United States who are in the country unlawfully, and investigates cross-border crime. Supporters say it enforces laws Congress passed; critics say its methods are abusive and want it reined in or replaced. Abolishing it would take an act of Congress, and its jobs would move elsewhere rather than vanish.

Today's story · 22 November 2026

Lobby Market Winner: Fully release the Epstein files with only victims names redacted

Should the DOJ release all Epstein files with only victims' names redacted?

▶ Play today's story

Read the briefing first

Agora players, live

See all 6 player splits on this issue

Latest Agora stories on this issue

All 7 stories on this issue

What ICE does

ICE was created in 2003, when the Homeland Security Act of 2002 broke up the old Immigration and Naturalization Service and the U.S. Customs Service and folded their work into the new Department of Homeland Security.

It has two main arms. Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) finds, arrests, detains and deports people who are removable under immigration law. Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) investigates crimes that cross borders: smuggling, human trafficking, drugs, child exploitation and fraud.

ICE is not the Border Patrol. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) guards the border and ports of entry; ICE works in the interior, which is why its arrests happen in cities, workplaces and courthouses, and why they draw so much attention.

Why people argue about it

"Abolish ICE" became a rallying cry in 2018, after children were separated from their parents at the border under the zero-tolerance policy. Since then the fight has been over how ICE operates as much as whether it should exist: arrests at courthouses and schools, detention conditions, body cameras, masks, and how much local police should help.

Cities and states take opposite sides. Some "sanctuary" jurisdictions limit cooperation with ICE; others sign agreements to help it. Agora's stories on New York's mayor telling residents their rights during ICE encounters, on when ICE will release body-camera footage and on ICE's plan to give officers electric-shock gloves are all versions of that fight.

What would happen if ICE were abolished

Because ICE exists by law, ending it would need Congress to pass a new law and a president to sign it (or a veto override). An executive order could change priorities, not abolish the agency.

Immigration law would still be on the books. Most abolition bills, starting with one filed in the House in 2018, proposed moving ICE's necessary jobs elsewhere: investigations to the Justice Department or another agency, and deportation work to a new or reorganised body with new rules. Supporters call that a fresh start; opponents call it abolishing enforcement under another name.

The practical effects would depend on what replaced it: fewer interior arrests and detentions if enforcement were scaled back, or much the same if the work simply moved.

The case for abolishing or sharply reining in ICE

  • Interior raids and courthouse arrests make immigrant communities afraid to report crimes, go to school or see a doctor.
  • Detention conditions and deaths in custody show an agency that is too hard to hold to account.
  • HSI's criminal investigations could be done by agencies that don't also run deportations.
  • Most people without papers have lived in the U.S. for years; deporting them splits families and costs the economy workers.

The case for keeping or expanding ICE

  • Laws passed by Congress need enforcing; without an interior agency, anyone who gets past the border could stay.
  • ICE removes people convicted of serious crimes and investigates trafficking and smuggling networks.
  • Abolishing it would hand power to sanctuary policies that some voters never chose.
  • Fixing specific problems (training, cameras, oversight) is better than tearing down an agency and starting again.

Common questions

Can the president abolish ICE?

No. ICE was set up under the Homeland Security Act, so abolishing it takes a new law passed by Congress. A president can change who ICE targets and how, but not end it alone.

What's the difference between ICE and Border Patrol?

Border Patrol (part of CBP) works at the border and ports of entry. ICE works inside the country: arrests, detention, deportation and cross-border criminal investigations.

Does abolishing ICE mean open borders?

Not by itself. Border Patrol would still guard the border and immigration law would still apply. The argument is over who enforces it inside the country, and how.

Key facts and sources

  • ICE was created in March 2003 under the Department of Homeland Security. (ICE: history)
  • ICE's two main operational arms are Enforcement and Removal Operations and Homeland Security Investigations. (ICE: about)
  • The 2018 House bill to abolish ICE proposed a commission to move its essential functions to other agencies. (Congress.gov, H.R. 6361 (115th Congress))

What Agora players think

The side players picked before playing each story. Live from Agora games, not a scientific poll.

Every Agora story on this issue

More on Immigration and ICE

Today's story · 22 November 2026

Lobby Market Winner: Fully release the Epstein files with only victims names redacted

Should the DOJ release all Epstein files with only victims' names redacted?

▶ Play today's story

Read the briefing first

Written by the Agora team from the sources above. Player numbers update as people play.