Agora issue guide
Should Congress and the Supreme Court have term limits?
By the Agora desk · Published · How we count player splits
A president can serve only two terms, but members of Congress can be re-elected as often as voters like and Supreme Court justices serve for life. Term limits for both are popular in polls. Limiting Congress would need a constitutional amendment; for the Court, some argue an ordinary law would do.
Agora players, live
Should the surrogate have parental rights over the baby?
Yes 45%No 55%
49 players · U.S. Supreme Court declines to give surrogate custody of baby she birthed, 23 September 2026 · Cite or embed
Latest Agora stories on this issue
The rules today
The 22nd Amendment, ratified in 1951 after Franklin Roosevelt won four elections, limits a president to two elected terms. Nothing similar applies to Congress: senators serve six-year terms and representatives two-year terms, with no cap on re-election. In 1995, in U.S. Term Limits v. Thornton, the Supreme Court ruled that states cannot impose term limits on their own members of Congress.
Federal judges, including Supreme Court justices, "hold their offices during good behaviour" under Article III, which in practice means for life unless they retire or are impeached and removed. Many states limit their own officials: 16 states cap how long state legislators can serve.
Why people argue about it
Supporters say long careers breed insiders tied to donors and lobbyists, and that justices now serve far longer than the founders could have expected, so every vacancy becomes a political war. Opponents say voters can already remove anyone they want, and that limits push out experience and hand power to lobbyists and staff, who face no limits.
Agora asked players whether all elected officials should face age and term limits. Players have also weighed what the Court decides and declines to decide, from a surrogate's custody fight it chose not to hear to the Trump administration's request to set aside California mail ballots, which it rejected.
What it would take
A constitutional amendment needs two-thirds of both the House and the Senate, then ratification by three-quarters of the states (38). That is why congressional term limits have never passed despite their popularity: they ask members to vote to limit themselves.
For the Supreme Court there are two routes. A proposed amendment introduced in May 2026 (H.J.Res. 174) would cap a justice's service at 18 years. Senate Democrats instead back a bill that would give each president two appointments per term and move justices off the Court after 18 years, which they say needs no amendment. Critics say any law cutting a justice's tenure would clash with Article III and be struck down.
The case for term limits
- Fresh faces bring new ideas and break the hold of long-serving incumbents and their donors.
- Fixed 18-year terms would give every president the same number of Supreme Court picks and cool confirmation fights.
- Life tenure lets justices time their retirements for political advantage.
- Polls show large majorities in both parties support them.
The case against term limits
- Voters already have a term limit: elections. Limits take away their right to keep someone they trust.
- Lawmakers would leave just as they learn the job, giving more power to lobbyists, staff and agencies.
- Life tenure was meant to free judges from political pressure; term limits would make the Court more political, not less.
- Changing the Court by ordinary law invites a constitutional fight and tit-for-tat changes by the next majority.
Common questions
Do members of Congress have term limits?
No. Senators and representatives can be re-elected as many times as voters choose, and the Supreme Court ruled in 1995 that states can't limit them. Adding limits would take a constitutional amendment.
Why do Supreme Court justices serve for life?
Article III says federal judges hold office "during good behaviour". The aim was to shield judges from pressure by politicians and voters so they could rule against either.
Could Congress set Supreme Court term limits without an amendment?
Possibly, and it is disputed. Some bills would keep justices as federal judges for life but move them off the Supreme Court after 18 years. Supporters say that fits the Constitution; opponents expect the Court to strike it down.
Key facts and sources
- The 22nd Amendment limits a president to two elected terms. (Cornell Legal Information Institute, 22nd Amendment)
- In U.S. Term Limits v. Thornton (1995) the Supreme Court held that states cannot add term limits for members of Congress. (Cornell Legal Information Institute, 514 U.S. 779)
- Federal judges hold their offices during good behaviour (Article III, Section 1). (Cornell Legal Information Institute, Article III)
- Amendments need two-thirds of both houses of Congress and ratification by three-quarters of the states (Article V). (Cornell Legal Information Institute, Article V)
- H.J.Res. 174 (2026) proposes a constitutional amendment limiting Supreme Court justices to 18 years. (GovInfo, H.J.Res. 174 (119th Congress))
- 16 states limit the terms of state legislators. (Ballotpedia)
What Agora players think
The side players picked before playing each story. Live from Agora games, not a scientific poll.
Should California count these disputed ballots?
Yes 56%No 44%
25 players · Supreme Court rejects Trump bid to set aside California ballots, 3 November 2026 · Cite or embed
Should the surrogate have parental rights over the baby?
Yes 45%No 55%
49 players · U.S. Supreme Court declines to give surrogate custody of baby she birthed, 23 September 2026 · Cite or embed
Every Agora story on this issue
Written by the Agora team from the sources above. Player numbers update as people play.
