New York and Mamdani ·
Mamdani Disbands NYC Police Protest Unit
What happened
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced the disbandment of the police department's Strategic Response Group. The move fulfills a campaign promise to separate counterterrorism operations from protest policing. Approximately 500 officers from the unit will be reassigned before spring 2027.
The Strategic Response Group was established in 2015 to handle both counterterrorism and protest policing in New York City. Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced his candidacy in October 2024 on a progressive platform that included public safety reform. He was elected as the city's 112th mayor in November 2025 and sworn in on January 1, 2026.
Why it matters
Why did Mamdani do it?
The unit faced accusations of excessive force during the 2020 George Floyd protests, resulting in a 2023 legal settlement. Mamdani promised to disband it during his election campaign. His reforms also restrict tear gas, pepper spray and aggressive crowd-control tactics.
How each side sees it
Left-leaning coverage
The Guardian: Mamdani disbands NYPD unit accused of using excessive force
- The unit faced years of accusations of excessive force and aggressive tactics against protesters, particularly during the 2020 demonstrations.
- Mamdani fulfilled a major campaign promise to disband the unit, arguing peaceful protesters should not be treated like terrorists.
- A new civilian-led division will focus on communication and de-escalation, without weapons or powers of arrest.
Right-leaning coverage
Fox News: Police groups condemn Mamdani over axing elite NYPD unit
- Police unions condemned Mamdani's decision, arguing the specialist unit was essential for protecting officers and civilians during dangerous protests.
- Police Benevolent Association president Patrick Hendry warned that demonstrations blocking bridges and roads could disrupt ordinary New Yorkers.
- Critics accused Mamdani of prioritising his political supporters over public safety, while the mayor insisted the changes would protect constitutional rights.
The full story
Mamdani stated that New Yorkers exercising their right to protest should not face a terrorism-style police response. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch supports the overhaul, noting that the changes will make the department stronger and more effective. The new structure will be implemented without changing the size of the police workforce or adding costs.
Police Benevolent Association President Patrick Hendry strongly criticized the disbandment, arguing it compromises public safety and officer well-being. Hendry claimed the mayor is putting safety at risk to appease a radical base. Critics are questioning whether the replacement units will truly represent a fundamental shift in policing practices or merely rebrand existing functions.
The overhaul aims to transform how the city prepares for demonstrations while maintaining public order. The new First Amendment Support Team will consist of 30 officers, and the new limit for acoustic devices used during protests is 90 decibels. Civil liberties groups welcomed the disbandment as a victory for First Amendment rights.
The police department will create a new Patrol Support Division as part of the revised approach to crowd management. Officers from the disbanded unit will be reassigned to other duties within the department before spring 2027. An unarmed civilian-led team will help de-escalate demonstrations moving forward.
What players think
Agora players · live
71% said No
Was Mamdani right to disband the unit?
Yes 29%No 71%
24 players picked a side before playing · How it's counted
Cite this
Quote it as: "71% of 24 Agora players said No." Link:
Embed the live card on your site:
Common questions
Why is it controversial?
Police unions warn the changes could leave New Yorkers less safe during violent protests. Civil rights groups support the move but fear the replacement could repeat past abuses. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch insists the restructuring will preserve public safety.
Sources and further reading
- LeftThe Guardian: Mamdani disbands NYPD unit accused of using excessive force
- Center-LeftCNN: Mamdani disbands controversial NYPD unit, fulfilling campaign promise
- CenterReuters: New York Mayor Mamdani disbands 'notorious' police unit that used excessive force on protesters
- Center-RightDeseret News: Mamdani moves to disband NYPD protest unit
- RightFox News: Police groups condemn Mamdani over axing elite NYPD unit
Related
Play this story
Was Mamdani right to disband the unit? Pick a side, answer a few quick questions, then see how other players split.
Play this storyFree · no sign-up to start · about 5 minutes
