AGORA

Talking politics

Why is politics so polarised?

By the Agora desk · Published · How we count player splits

There's no single cause. Researchers point to a mix: the parties sorting into more distinct camps by ideology, race, religion and place; a news world split along party lines; and politics that rewards conflict. The evidence is strongest for sorting, and weaker than many people assume for social media and primary elections.

In short

  • Polarisation has two meanings: how far apart people's views are, and how much they dislike the other side. The second has grown faster.
  • The US stands out: in one study of wealthy democracies, it had the biggest rise in partisan dislike.
  • Sorting (parties lining up with ideology, race, religion and geography) is the best-supported explanation.
  • Partisan media probably plays a part; the case against social media and primaries is weaker than its reputation.
  • Researchers disagree on the weights, and nobody has a single proven fix.

Practise on today's story · 22 November 2026

Lobby Market Winner: Fully release the Epstein files with only victims names redacted

Should the DOJ release all Epstein files with only victims' names redacted?

▶ Play today's story

Read the briefing first

Two kinds of polarisation

Researchers separate ideological polarisation (people's policy views moving apart) from affective polarisation (people disliking and distrusting the other side). Both have grown in the US, but the second has grown faster, and it's what makes politics feel so hostile.

Pew Research Center's long-running surveys show both. The share of Americans with consistently liberal or consistently conservative views rose from 10% in 1994 to 21% in 2014. Over the same period, the share of Republicans with a very unfavourable view of the Democratic Party rose from 17% to 43%, and the share of Democrats with a very unfavourable view of the Republican Party rose from 16% to 38%.

That pattern matters for how you read the rest of this page: much of the story is about identity and feeling, not just policy.

Sorting: the parties became more different from each other

For much of the 20th century, both main US parties contained liberals and conservatives. Over the past few decades, voters have sorted: conservatives have increasingly ended up in one party and liberals in the other. Pew's rise in consistently liberal or conservative views is one sign of this.

Sorting goes beyond ideology. Economists Levi Boxell, Matthew Gentzkow and Jesse Shapiro, comparing a dozen wealthy democracies, found most support for explanations based on sorting: the gap between the parties' ideologies grew faster in the US and Canada than elsewhere, and growing racial diversity and sorting along racial and religious lines also appeared to play a part. When your party lines up with your religion, your neighbourhood and your friends, losing an election can feel like a threat to who you are.

Media: different sources, different realities

Pew found in 2019 that Republicans and Democrats trusted "two nearly inverse news media environments": most outlets trusted by one side were distrusted by the other, and no source out of 30 was trusted by more than half of all US adults.

The same cross-country study found the timing of 24-hour partisan cable news in the 1990s was roughly consistent with an acceleration in US partisan dislike, and that countries where polarisation fell spent more per person on public broadcasting. That's suggestive, not proof: it's hard to tell whether partisan media makes people more partisan or partisan people seek out partisan media. Most researchers think it's some of both.

Geography: living apart

Americans increasingly live near people who vote like them. Political scientists Jacob Brown and Ryan Enos mapped where more than 180 million registered voters live and found that a large share have almost no exposure to voters from the other party in their area, even within the same city.

Why this happens is debated. Some argue people move to places that match their values; others argue they move for jobs, house prices and lifestyle (cities versus suburbs and countryside) that happen to line up with party. Either way, if you rarely meet the other side in daily life, it's easier to picture them as a caricature.

Social media and primaries: weaker evidence than you'd think

Social media is the most popular explanation, but it doesn't fit the timing well. US polarisation was rising before social media existed, and the cross-country study found internet access grew in every country, including the ones where polarisation fell. A large 2023 experiment on Facebook during the 2020 US election cut how much content users saw from like-minded sources by about a third, and found no measurable effect on polarisation or extreme views over the study period. Social media may still amplify outrage, shape what politicians say or matter more for some groups; researchers are still arguing about that.

Primary elections, where only party loyalists pick candidates, are often blamed for pushing politicians to the edges. But a well-known 2010 study of the US Congress found little evidence that primaries, primary turnout or the threat of a primary challenge were linked to more polarised voting. Competitive general elections, by contrast, did pull politicians towards the centre. This is still an active debate, and reforms such as open or top-two primaries are being tried in several states.

Is it the same in the UK?

Not in the same way. In the cross-country study, measured partisan dislike fell over recent decades in Britain, Australia, Norway, Sweden and Germany, while it rose most in the US. The data run to the mid-2010s, so they don't capture everything since.

Britain has its own divides that cut across party lines, such as the 2016 Brexit referendum. But if American politics feels uniquely bitter, the data back that up.

Common questions

Is the US more polarised than other countries?

On partisan dislike, the US saw the largest increase of the wealthy democracies in Boxell, Gentzkow and Shapiro's study, rising by almost 70% between 1978 and 2016 on their measure. Several other countries rose more modestly, and some fell.

Which side is more to blame?

Researchers disagree, and the answer depends on what you measure: politicians' voting records, voters' views or how each side feels about the other. Some political scientists argue one party has moved further than the other; others dispute the measures. Surveys show hostility runs in both directions, which is why this page focuses on causes rather than blame.

Is polarisation always a bad thing?

Not entirely. Clear differences between parties give voters a real choice, and some political scientists once complained the parties were too similar. The problems come when dislike turns into distrust of elections, refusal to compromise, or seeing opponents as enemies rather than fellow citizens.

Can polarisation be reduced?

It has fallen in some countries, so it isn't a one-way street. At the personal level, studies find people overestimate how extreme the other side is, and correcting that picture helps. See how to talk politics with family and how to get out of your echo chamber.

Sources and further reading

Put it into practice: latest stories

Every story

Written by the Agora desk from the sources above. See our editorial standards. More Learn articles.