Getting into politics
How do I form my own political opinions?
By the Agora desk · Published · How we count player splits
Take one issue at a time. Find out what the problem is and how the main options would work, hear the strongest case for each side in its own words, and work out whether you disagree about facts or about values. Then decide, and hold the view with as much confidence as the evidence allows.
In short
- Start from a question ("what should happen to X?"), not from a team.
- If you can't explain how a policy would work, you're not ready to be sure about it.
- You understand an argument when you can state the other side's case so its supporters would agree.
- Split disagreements into facts (checkable) and values (what matters most to you).
- It's fine to have no opinion yet, or a tentative one.
Why this is hard
Most political opinions aren't built from scratch. People pick them up from family, friends, the outlets they read and the party they feel closest to, then find reasons later. That's normal human behaviour, not a personal failing. But it means "repeating what my side says" is the default, and forming your own view takes a deliberate method.
The good news is that you don't need a view on everything. Pew Research Center's 2026 political typology found that most Americans, in both parties, are neither consistently liberal nor consistently conservative in their values. Holding a mix of views is the norm.
Step 1: start with a specific question
"Am I left or right?" is too big to answer. "Should my city build more housing near the station?" or "Should the minimum wage go up?" are questions you can actually work through.
Write the question down in neutral words. If your question already contains the answer ("Why is X so bad?"), rewrite it.
Step 2: learn how it would actually work
Find out what the problem is, what the main options are, and what each one would do in practice: who pays, who benefits, what changes on day one and in five years, and what has happened where it was tried.
This step matters more than it sounds. In a 2013 study in Psychological Science, Fernbach and colleagues asked people to explain in detail how policies such as a cap-and-trade scheme would work. Their confidence in their own understanding fell, and their views became more moderate. Simply listing reasons for their view didn't have the same effect. Later attempts to repeat the study found the drop in confidence more consistently than the shift to moderation, but the lesson stands: explaining the mechanism shows you where your knowledge runs out.
Try it yourself: explain the policy out loud, step by step, as if to a friend. Where you get stuck is where to read next.
Step 3: hear the strongest case for each side
Read each side's best arguments, made by people who actually hold them, not the weakest version as described by their opponents. Opinion pieces from both sides, party manifestos and platforms, and explainers that set out the case for and against are all useful. Agora's issue guides, such as the one on tariffs, lay out each side's case in its supporters' own terms.
A good test: can you state the other side's view so well that someone who holds it would say "yes, that's exactly why I think that"? If not, you don't yet know what you're disagreeing with. As John Stuart Mill put it in On Liberty (1859), "He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that."
Agora's daily stories work on the same idea: you read a short briefing, pick a side, and then see how other players split (see how we count).
Step 4: separate facts from values
Most political arguments mix two kinds of disagreement, and it helps to pull them apart.
- Facts: questions evidence can answer, at least in principle. Does this policy reduce crime? How much would it cost? What happened when another country tried it? Check these with good sources (see how to check if a source is reliable) and be willing to change your mind.
- Values: questions about what matters most. Freedom or security? Fairness as equal treatment or as equal outcomes? Present needs or future costs? Evidence can't settle these; you have to decide what you care about.
- Often people agree on the facts and differ on values, or share values and differ on facts. Knowing which one you're in makes the conversation, and your own thinking, much clearer.
Step 5: decide, then stay open
Now pick a view and say why in a sentence or two. It's fine to hold it loosely: "I lean towards X, mainly because of Y, but I'd change my mind if Z turned out to be true." Naming the Z is the most useful part.
Watch for a few traps. Be suspicious when every one of your views lines up with one party, when you find yourself only reading sources that agree with you, or when you feel certain about something you couldn't explain in Step 2. These are signs you're borrowing a package rather than forming opinions.
Quizzes such as Pew Research Center's political typology quiz can show where your answers sit compared with other people. Treat the result as a mirror, not a label you have to live up to.
Common questions
How do I stop just repeating what I've heard?
Before you share a view, try to explain how the policy would work and state the best argument against it. If you can't do either, you've picked up a conclusion without the reasoning, and that's the bit to go and learn.
Is it bad to change my mind?
No. Changing your mind when you learn something new is the point of forming opinions properly. Being able to say what would change your mind is a sign of a well-founded view.
Should I just take the middle position on everything?
Not automatically. The middle isn't always right, and splitting the difference skips the thinking. Work through the question, and if you land in the middle, that's fine too.
How do I know which sources to trust while I'm learning?
Use more than one outlet, check unfamiliar sites by seeing what other sources say about them ("lateral reading"), and prefer original documents and data where you can. See how to read the news critically.
Sources and further reading
- Fernbach, Rogers, Fox and Sloman (2013), Political Extremism Is Supported by an Illusion of Understanding, Psychological Science
- Pew Research Center (2026): Beyond Red vs. Blue: The Political Typology
- Pew Research Center: Political Typology Quiz
- Digital Inquiry Group, Civic Online Reasoning: Teaching lateral reading
- News Literacy Project
Read next
- What's the difference between left and right in politics?Where the terms come from, what left and right usually mean on the economy and social issues in the US and UK, and why most people don't fit neatly.
- How do I get out of my political echo chamber?How to widen your political view: what research says about echo chambers, a simple plan to diversify your news, and why following trolls backfires.
- How do I read a news story critically?A step-by-step checklist: spot news vs opinion, read past the headline, check sources and numbers, notice what's missing and check other coverage.
Put it into practice: latest stories
Written by the Agora desk from the sources above. See our editorial standards. More Learn articles.
