Agora issue guide
What would happen if the Federal Reserve was abolished?
By the Agora desk · Published · How we count player splits
The Federal Reserve is America's central bank. It sets short-term interest rates, lends to banks in a crisis and supervises much of the banking system. Critics say it holds too much unelected power; supporters say its independence from politicians is what keeps inflation in check. Abolishing it would take an act of Congress, and Congress would then have to decide who does its jobs.
Agora players, live
Should the US government cut spending to bring borrowing costs down?
Yes 91%No 9%
43 players · US borrowing costs hit highest level in decades, 1 October 2026 · Cite or embed
Latest Agora stories on this issue
What the Fed does
Congress created the Federal Reserve with the Federal Reserve Act of 1913, after a run of banking panics. It has three parts: a Board of Governors in Washington, whose seven members are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate; twelve regional Reserve Banks; and the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), which sets interest rates.
Congress gave it two main goals, often called the dual mandate: maximum employment and stable prices. It raises rates to cool inflation and cuts them to support jobs, and in crises such as 2008 and 2020 it lends to banks and markets when no one else will.
Is it privately owned? Only in a narrow sense. Commercial banks that belong to the system must hold stock in their regional Reserve Bank, but that stock cannot be sold or traded and does not carry the control that ordinary shares do. The Board of Governors is a federal agency, and the Fed hands its earnings, after expenses, to the Treasury.
Why people argue about it
"End the Fed" is an old cause, mostly of libertarians and parts of the right. Ron Paul first filed a bill to abolish it in 1999. In March 2025 Rep. Thomas Massie and Sen. Mike Lee introduced the Federal Reserve Board Abolition Act, which would abolish the Board and every Reserve Bank a year after it passed and repeal the Federal Reserve Act. Agora asked players whether Congress should abolish the Federal Reserve.
The bigger fight in 2025 and 2026 has been over independence rather than abolition. President Trump pressed the Fed to cut rates faster and tried to remove Governor Lisa Cook; in June 2026 the Supreme Court let her keep her job while her case goes on. Rates matter to the government too, because they set what it pays to borrow: Agora players argued over spending cuts when U.S. borrowing costs hit their highest level in decades.
What would happen if the Fed was abolished
Congress would have to pass a law and the president sign it. The Fed's jobs would not vanish with it: someone would still have to issue the currency, run the payment systems banks use to move money, supervise banks and decide how much money is in circulation.
Abolitionists propose different replacements: a gold standard or other commodity money that limits how much money can be created, competing private currencies, or handing the job to the Treasury. Defenders of the Fed warn that money run by elected politicians tempts them to stoke a boom before each election, and that without a lender of last resort the bank panics of the 1800s and early 1900s could return.
Short of abolition, the live proposals are about control: auditing the Fed's rate decisions, narrowing its mandate to prices alone, or making it easier for a president to remove governors.
The case for abolishing or reining in the Fed
- Unelected officials make decisions that move every mortgage, wage and savings account, with little direct answer to voters.
- Creating money erodes the dollar: it has lost most of its buying power since the Fed was founded.
- Low rates and bailouts reward banks and Wall Street and inflate asset bubbles.
- Easy money lets Washington borrow and spend more than it otherwise could.
The case for keeping an independent Fed
- Independence keeps the printing press away from politicians who want a boom before every election.
- As lender of last resort it stopped the 2008 and 2020 panics from becoming depressions.
- A gold standard ties the money supply to mining output, and many economists blame it for deepening the Great Depression.
- Its earnings go to the Treasury, and Congress can change its mandate whenever it chooses.
Common questions
Is the Federal Reserve privately owned?
Not in the usual sense. Member banks must hold stock in their regional Reserve Bank, but they can't sell it or run the bank the way shareholders run a company. The Board of Governors is a federal agency, and the Fed's earnings go to the Treasury.
Can the president abolish the Federal Reserve?
No. It was created by an act of Congress, so only Congress can abolish it. The president nominates the governors and the chair, and the Senate confirms them.
Should the Federal Reserve be independent?
Supporters say yes, because central banks run by politicians tend to allow more inflation. Critics say independence means a powerful body answers to no one. The 2025–26 fight over removing a governor was about exactly this.
Key facts and sources
- The Federal Reserve was created by the Federal Reserve Act of 1913. (Federal Reserve: Federal Reserve Act)
- Member banks hold stock in their Reserve Bank, but it is quite different from owning stock in a private company and cannot be sold or traded. (Federal Reserve: Who owns the Federal Reserve?)
- The FOMC's voting members are the seven governors, the president of the New York Fed and four other Reserve Bank presidents in rotation. (Federal Reserve: Federal Open Market Committee)
- H.R. 1846 (2025) would abolish the Board of Governors and each Reserve Bank one year after enactment and repeal the Federal Reserve Act. (GovInfo, H.R. 1846 (119th Congress))
- In June 2026 the Supreme Court, 5–4, let Governor Lisa Cook stay in her job while she challenges her removal. (OPB / AP, 29 June 2026)
What Agora players think
The side players picked before playing each story. Live from Agora games, not a scientific poll.
Should the US government cut spending to bring borrowing costs down?
Yes 91%No 9%
43 players · US borrowing costs hit highest level in decades, 1 October 2026 · Cite or embed
Every Agora story on this issue
Written by the Agora team from the sources above. Player numbers update as people play.
